The Gay is Here to Stay…At Least for Now


By: Jacqui Aguirre
In the famous words of Jay-Z, allow me to reintroduce myself. As you may have seen in
my interview with Carlos earlier this month, my name is Jacqui Aguirre, and I’m returning to
Cascade Media as a contributor to What’s Up Latin America. I’m also going to be the lead writer
on a column for legal news—I’m a lawyer, and there’s a flood of changes going on in the legal
landscape right now that not enough people are talking about, because who in their right mind
wants to spend all that time detangling legal nonsense? So, in the name of being informed, I’ll be
breaking it down so you don’t have to.
Before I jump into my first article, I want to give you a quick bio on me—so you know
the breakdown you’re getting in this column is legitimate. I graduated from the University of
Notre Dame with a Bachelor of Arts degree in History and one in Spanish in 2019. I then
returned to Notre Dame Law School and graduated with my J.D. from there in 2023. I am
licensed to practice law in the state of Missouri and have been working at a corporate defense
firm in Kansas City since graduation. I do a lot of personal injury defense and work with
products that may have injured people, but I also have experience in immigration and
international law, civil rights law, and politics. All this to say: I pinkie promise that I’m qualified
to explain legal stuff to you—and if I’m not, best believe I’ll be getting the breakdown from
someone who is.
So to start off my first article nice and easy, I’m going to be talking about the history of
same-sex marriage in the United States. “Jacqui,” you might be saying, “that’s got to be a crazy
long history. Why are we talking about it now?” To which I say, you’d actually be surprised at
the relatively short history of equal rights for our LGBTQ guys, gals, and nonbinary pals. And
the reason we’re handling it this week is because we just got a super important update from the
Supreme Court of the United States (“Supreme Court” or “SCOTUS”) in this area, and I want to
make sure everyone understands the gravity of that decision—because with the way important
protections have been falling under the current SCOTUS, this was a major victory for equal
rights.
The history of LGBTQ equal rights in this country from a legal perspective actually starts
a mere 22 years ago, in 2003. That June, the Supreme Court ruled on a case called Lawrence v.
Texas that really started the ball rolling on what would become the campaign for same-sex
marriage. Before we dive into what Lawrence changed, let me explain how laws, generally
speaking, work in this country. We have what’s called the Constitution, which lays out some
binding rules that no one can contradict or overturn (at least, not without Congress going through
a really complicated process to amend or change the Constitution). This would include things
like freedom of speech, religion, and assembly; the right to bear arms; and the right to not be
forced to house and feed military troops. Because these rights are laid out in the Constitution, no
state can pass laws that get rid of them or fundamentally impede them—that make them useless
in practice. The Constitution also has what’s called the Supremacy Clause. That means that any
law passed by the federal government (as long as it doesn’t mess with those rights that are clearly

laid out in the Constitution) take precedence over any laws passed by individual states. This
would include things like immigration: Congress gets to make the rules on who can come into
the country and how and individual states don’t get to say any different. But the Constitution also
explicitly reserved for the states any powers that weren’t specifically given to the federal
government (like immigration) or prohibited to the states (like getting rid of freedom of religion)
with the lovely and somewhat obscure Tenth Amendment. That basically means that the states
get to pass their own laws, as long as those laws aren’t on things that the Constitution gave to the
federal government or specifically told the states they can’t do. This is why laws in Missouri are
different than laws in Kansas or Texas or California. Each state can kind of do its own thing, as
long as they don’t overstep and get into territory that’s specifically reserved for the federal
government.
This leads us into Lawrence v. Texas. In 2003, a bunch of states (including, you guessed
it, Texas) had anti-sodomy laws that criminalized most intimate conduct between people of the
same sex. In Lawrence, police in Houston responded to a reported weapons disturbance at a
private residence. When they entered the home, they saw the owner of the apartment—a man
named John Lawrence—engaging in private and consensual sexual contact with another man.
Both Lawrence and the other man were arrested and convicted of deviant sexual conduct under
Texas’s anti-sodomy law. Lawrence appealed his conviction up to the Texas State Court of
Appeals—an appeals court, or a court that you can ask to review the decision of the court that
rules against you—which held that Texas’s sodomy law was not unconstitutional. Lawrence then
appealed up to the Supreme Court, which is called a “court of last resort”—meaning that it’s the
last court you can ask to review a legal decision.
“But Jacqui,” you may say, “why was the Supreme Court allowed to review this case?
Didn’t it involve a Texas law?” To which I’d say: yes, and there are a lot of times that the
Supreme Court cannot review state laws—those would be reviewed by the “court of last resort”
in your state, like the Missouri Supreme Court. But in this case, Lawrence argued that Texas’s
sodomy law was a violation of the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment—which is
part of the Constitution—which means that this case presented what’s called a “constitutional
question,” or a question involving the Constitution. Those types of questions are in SCOTUS’s
jurisdiction, which means that even though it’s a state law, the Supreme Court is the court of last
resort and can review it to make sure that it isn’t unconstitutional—that it doesn’t violate the
Constitution. Now, an interesting tidbit is that courts of last resort don’t have to hear a case, even
if they are allowed to hear it. That means it’s up to SCOTUS whether they want to hear a
case—which they often will if a state law is being accused of being unconstitutional.
Here, the part of the Constitution that Lawrence was arguing Texas violated was the
Fourteenth Amendment, which states:
All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction
thereof, are citizens of the United States and the State wherein they reside. No
State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or
immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person

of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person
within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the law.
Well, what the heck does that mean? It basically means any person who is born in the US
or who becomes a US citizen is, well, a citizen, which means that states can’t treat their rights
differently from state to state. The Fourteenth Amendment was one of the three Amendments
passed after the Civil War and was initially intended to address the problem of slavery—and
specifically, of slaves not being citizens, even though they were born here, and therefore being
treated wildly differently across state lines. But the Fourteenth Amendment also says that states
can’t deprive any person of their life, freedom, or stuff without going through proper legal
process—also known as the Due Process Clause—and that states can’t deny any person equal
protection under their laws—also known as the Equal Protection Clause. That means you don’t
have to be a citizen to enjoy certain legal protections. And, for our purposes, it means that states
can’t treat people unequally under their laws.
Well, Lawrence, argued, the Texas sodomy laws treat gay people and straight people
differently when it comes to sexual acts—that’s a violation of the Fourteenth Amendment. So
Lawrence went up to SCOTUS and asked two question: 1) does the Texas law that criminalizes
sexual intimacy by same-sex couples—but not identical behavior by different-sex
couples—violate the equal protection guarantee of the Fourteenth Amendment?; and 2) did
Lawrence’s criminal conviction for consensual sexual acts in the privacy of his own home violate
the Fourteenth Amendment’s protection of “liberty?”
SCOTUS at that time was comprised of three firm conservative justices (Scalia,
Rehnquist, and Thomas), four firm liberal justices (Stevens, Ginsburg, Souter, and Breyer), and
two swing justices that tended to lean more conservative (O’Connor and Kennedy). In Lawrence,
the four liberal justices and two swing justices combined for a 6-3 opinion that said the answers
to those two questions were both “yes.” The majority said that treating gay people and straight
people differently in the area of sexual conduct violates the Fourteenth Amendment’s rule on
equal protection. And, it added, the Fourteenth Amendment’s right to liberty means that adults
are free to engage in conduct in private without the government being all up in their business. So
after that incredibly long journey we just went on, the end result of Lawrence was
basically…anti-sodomy laws that target gay people are unconstitutional. Or, in other words, you
can’t outlaw gay sex. But this marked a massive first step: SCOTUS recognizing that state laws
weren’t allowed to unfairly target gay people.
The next big case for LGBTQ rights was actually a state case: Goodridge v. Department
of Public Health, in 2004 in Massachusetts. In that case, the Massachusetts Supreme Court said
that same-sex couples had the right to get married. And this is a big deal because, if we go back
to the Fourteenth Amendment, there’s a line that says: “No State shall make or enforce any law
which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States.” This means
that Kansas doesn’t get to make laws that target the rights of people in Missouri. Kansas has to
respect the “privileges”—or rights—of Missouri citizens, and all citizens of other states too, and
vice versa. So Goodridge is a big deal because now same-sex couples had the right to get
married in Massachusetts—and other states were supposed to respect that right. Well, that was a

problem, because a ton of states had laws against same-sex marriage which, those states argued,
meant they also didn’t have to recognize any gay marriages that were legal in the states they
came from. Meaning, if you legally got gay-married in Massachusetts and then moved to a state
like New York that did not recognize gay marriage, your marriage wasn’t legal. And, as more
states legalized same-sex marriage, this became more of an issue. And since that involves a
question of the Fourteenth Amendment, the Supreme Court eventually got involved. So in 2012,
the Supreme Court said states, while not yet required to recognize their own same-sex marriages,
did have to recognize same-sex marriages in other states in the case U.S. v. Windsor.
And then, in 2015, we got the big one: Obergefell v. Hodges. This is the Holy Grail of
LBTQ equal rights—the case in which SCOTUS, by a 5-4 margin, said that all states have to let
same-sex couples get married. Obergefell came about because groups of same-sex couples in
Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky, and Tennessee—states where gay marriage was not legal—sued
those states for refusing to let them get married. That refusal, these couples argued, violated the
Equal Protection Clause because it gave straight people a right that it didn’t give to gay people
because they were gay. And it also violated the Due Process Clause because it took away their
liberty to get married without proper legal procedures. And the Supreme Court agreed! SCOTUS
said the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees the right to get married as a fundamental
freedom—and that applies to same-sex couples, just like it does for straight couples. Marriage,
the Supreme Court, said, is a fundamental liberty because: 1) it is so closely tied to individual
autonomy; 2) marriage protects the most intimate connection you can have with another person;
3) it protects children and the family by allowing people to build a home and raise a family; and
4) marriage has historically been considered a keystone of society. And, SCOTUS added, there’s
no difference for gay people and straight people when it comes to those four things. Therefore,
denying same-sex couples the right to get married is a violation the Due Process Clause. What’s
more, the Equal Protection Clause guarantees the right to get married to same-sex couples and
different-sex couples equally.
We can dive into the details on the legal arguments on both sides of Obergefell some
other time (maybe on its anniversary?), but for this article, I’ll just say that a major opposition to
Obergefell is religious freedom. Basically, people argue that recognizing gay marriage is against
their religion, and therefore a violation of the Constitution’s First Amendment. This is an
especially central argument when discussing the Supreme Court’s decision on Monday that’s
prompting this article.
In 2015, a same-sex couple in Kentucky sued Kim Davis, a former Rowan County clerk,
for refusing to issue same-sex marriage licenses, even after Obergefell was decided. The couple
that sued her won (obviously), but Kim Davis appealed. The appellate court ruled against her
also, so she appealed up to the Supreme Court. Now, it’s a little misleading to say that this was
completely about same-sex marriage. It’s actually about liability. See, the couple that originally
sued Kim Davis won $360,00 dollars against her—$100,00 as an award and $260,000 in attorney
fees. That’s what she was appealing—the money, not the same-sex marriage bit. But people were
nervous that if the Supreme Court agreed to hear this case, it would necessarily involve revisiting
their decision in Obergefell because Kim Davis was arguing that she shouldn’t have to pay

money because it’s against her religion to issue same-sex marriage licenses, and therefore, a
violation of the First Amendment. If SCOTUS had agreed to hear that case, the fear was, then
that meant the Supreme Court would be recognizing that “religious freedom” is a valid basis to
deny same-sex marriage licenses. And if that was the case, it would only have been a matter of
time until that argument was made against Obergefell itself—the actual same-sex marriage bit.
“But Jacqui,” you might say, “can the Supreme Court even do that?” To which I say: yes,
but it’s complicated. SCOTUS doesn’t like to overturn itself for a lot of reasons, but the big one
is called “precedents.” Whatever the Supreme Court says goes. In other words, all the other
courts in the country have to issue rulings that align with whatever the Supreme Court says is
law. A ruling that other rulings are based on is called a “precedent.” And the more precedents
you have for something, the more legally safe a ruling is considered. Precedents aren’t
absolute—Brown vs. Board of Education famously overturned the precedent of Plessy v.
Ferguson on school integration—but the longer one is around, the more safe it’s considered to be
because so many legal rulings have been issued relying on it and so many people have made life
decisions with the understanding that the precedent is the controlling rule. The current SCOTUS,
however, is making a lot of people really nervous, even about things traditionally as protected as
precedents.
The current Supreme Court is made up of six conservative justices (Alito, Thomas,
Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, Roberts, and Barrett) and three liberal justices (Sotomayor, Kagan, and
Brown-Jackson). Three of the conservative justices—Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, and Barrett—were
nominated to SCOTUS by President Trump in his first administration. Now, judges aren’t
supposed to be political, per se, but a judge’s legal ideology is often considered to be code for
their politics. Judges with a conservative legal ideology are thought to make politically
conservative rulings as well, and that was a big concern when President Trump got three
nominations on SCOTUS—the concern, of course, being that six conservative justices would just
rubberstamp any conservative policies, regardless of whether they’re actually constitutional or
not. Now, obviously, the justices take a lot of offense if you say that to them, and it is true that
justices don’t always rule on the same side as their ideological peers—we’ve gotten some
interesting pairings under this SCOTUS that sees Barrett on the same side as the liberal justices,
or Kagan on the same side as Roberts. But the truth of the matter is, when it comes to big and
controversial decisions, these six justices can be counted on to favor the conservative
argument—even at the risk of overturning a precedent. We saw this most famously with the
Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health ruling in summer 2022 that overturned Roe v. Wade’s
constitutional right to an abortion, even though Roe was a 50-year-old precedent that’s been
relied on for hundreds of cases and millions of personal decisions.
Because of that, what used to be a certainty—that SCOTUS will not overturn itself
without insanely good cause and certainly not for something as partisan as political ideology—is
feared to no longer be safe. So there was a lot of anxiety that the Supreme Cout was going to
agree to hear Kim Davis’s appeal and start itself on the first step to overruling Obergefell and
taking the right to get married away from gay people. Now, actually overturning Obergefell
would probably leave us in a similar situation as abortion: some states would outlaw it, and some

wouldn’t. but there are currently 30 states that have laws on the books that would take away gay
marriage, should Obergefell be overturned. That’s thousands of people affected, and that risk is
more real now than it has been since Obergefell came down on a super thin 5-4 ruling.
All of this to say, it was a huge relief when SCOTUS declined to hear Kim Davis’s appeal
on Monday. And, at least for now, Obergefell is staying the law of the land.

nelson

📱 To Install This App

Scroll to Top